Xenforo 2 or IPS 4.2 (4.3 when released)

Discussion in 'Software & Hosting Discussions' started by Smokey, Jan 5, 2018.

Xenforo 2.0 or IPS 4.2?

  1. Xenforo 2

    3 vote(s)
    42.9%
  2. IPS 4.2

    4 vote(s)
    57.1%
  3. Other (Specify)

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  1. Smokey

    Smokey Paragon

    1,904
    49
    120
    +59
    1
    -0
    So i'm in a bit of a pickle here. I am starting up my new forums, I currently have them on ZetaBoards, however, with the practices over there with Tapatalk kinda turns me away from them and i'm looking to go for a paid solution......

    I have a Xenforo license and an IPS license. I'm not sure what to use.......Which would be a good solution for a general community?

    IPS I have the following add-ons: Board, Gallery, Blog, Pages.
    XF2: I have 2 licenses, 1 standalone forum and one with forum, resource manager & media gallery.

    Which do you feel offers more bang for your buck?

    Which software does everyone prefer for a community?

    List pro's and con's of both.
     
  2. Empire

    Empire Valued Contributor Valued Contributor

    16,855
    1,229
    320
    +1,697
    93
    -0
    IPS is more costly and expecting to pay out and good amount! like almost $1000 in over 2 years of me running my IPS forum.

    That being said once you have all paid plugins then after 2 years you start paying allot less until IPS release an new forum like 4.3 :p But end of all you do get what you pay for ;) support, unless updates, allot of plugins and you can request if there isn't an plugin.

    Then the hard part :( Xenforo is also very good. They are cheaper then IPS, but they do offer better themes or at least the way it's been design and how the profile looks, I mean FP is running off of that. IPS does offer very good themes , third party themes only like my website but they are not free. most IPS themes aren't free
     
  3. Smokey

    Smokey Paragon

    1,904
    49
    120
    +59
    1
    -0
    Yeah that's my issue. I'll probably end up going the XF2 route I think......I wanted to just stick with ZetaBoards but the way Tapatalk is looking, it doesn't look like ZB will be around for much longer. :(

    So i think self-hosted is my best bet anyway, I'll probably end up going the XF2 route.....my lady/co-admin prefers XF anyway so there's also that. :)
     
  4. Champion

    Champion Paragon

    1,491
    297
    130
    +334
    5
    -0
    Go with Xenforo lot of community uses it as its more cheaper.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  5. Löis

    Löis Reputable

    231
    52
    30
    +57
    1
    -0
    I have always preferred Xenforo to IPS so XF 2.0 gets my vote :p
     
  6. Empire

    Empire Valued Contributor Valued Contributor

    16,855
    1,229
    320
    +1,697
    93
    -0
    XF2 is responsiveness, so tapatalk isn't needed. And self-hosted is the way to go as you have more power and once you brought the forum pack you have it forever other then the renew fee
     
  7. Cessepedes17

    Cessepedes17 Paragon

    1,201
    55
    105
    +70
    10
    -0
    i have XF2 and i absolutely love it. i use hosting with HostGator.
     
  8. Smokey

    Smokey Paragon

    1,904
    49
    120
    +59
    1
    -0
    Not a fan of hostgator :p had bad experience with them years ago. :) I'm on Hawkhost, it's been fairly well so far :)

    Went with XF2, thanks guys! :D

    New Nucleus is now live! Just need a new theme (coming soon) and some other graphics which we're working on behind the scenes at the moment. :D
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  9. Empire

    Empire Valued Contributor Valued Contributor

    16,855
    1,229
    320
    +1,697
    93
    -0
    there on my list
     
    • Like Like x 1
  10. Smokey

    Smokey Paragon

    1,904
    49
    120
    +59
    1
    -0
    They are pretty decent. I've noticed some slow down today but i'm on their NYC server as I live in NY and the weather here hasn't been too great so I'm guessing that could be it, but it's not terribly a bad experience, it's definitely usable and XF2 runs well with no real issues on their shared hosting. :)
     
  11. Jason76

    Jason76 Packager Package Team

    3,179
    190
    135
    +252
    8
    -0
    XF 2, from what I've seen on the SWC forum, has a problem with email - in some cases. Note, when SWC switched to another host and the email format was turned off of SMTP, then there were no errors (Something that recently happened.).
     
  12. KnownSyntax

    KnownSyntax Up-and-Coming Sensation

    414
    14
    35
    +18
    0
    -0
    XenForo is nice if you want a simple community, but IPB has a lot more to offer (with the additional price). The only thing different is just the community, support level, and the quality of the product you end up with (interfaces, what has different features, etc.). Overall both have paid themes and very few "free" based themes/styles, and most plugins will cost money.

    My vote, IPB hands down.
     
  13. Jason76

    Jason76 Packager Package Team

    3,179
    190
    135
    +252
    8
    -0
    XF 2 has a free ad mod, though.