First Impressions - (Out of 20)
Wow! That's pretty much all i can say. I'm not even a Naruto, Bleach, or Soul Shurikan fan ... but seeing the forum, and the popularity it obviously has, i'm just struck in awe at the moment.
(18/20)
Site Layout - (Out of 20)
You're obvioulsy a huge fan of these genres, and know exactly what you're doing. The Board layout is exactly how it should be. And i like how you chose to have only one off-topic Board at the bottom. Very daring ... and it shows you're more into your forum's theme, and, also, leave a little room for non-RPG talk.
Alot of forums, myslef included, need more than just the theme to keep members interested, but you have made it work, all on it's own. I'm just really impressed with what you got, and how it works.
(18 /20)
Forum Statistics - (Out of 20)
Your Forum Stats shine like no other. Stellar members/posts count, and every board is posted in; and up to date.
I'm afraid if i say anything , i may mess up your forum stats. ~razz~ They are Golden. Keep doing whatever it is you're doing ... and share your secrets with the rest of us!
The one setback to such high numbers, is the low active members list when compared. I know i can't see all of them, but with 600+ members; i would've expected to see more than 30 members within the past 48 hours. And i did check by looking at the "current active topics"
(18/20)
Staff Moderation - (Out of 20)
It's past 2am where i am, and you already have 2 moderators working the night shift. I can only assume you have the necessary staff to moderate the forum, seeing how successful it is.
There are alot of forum ranks, and it could be hard for guests to differentate staff from these other ranks. But that's all , really.
(17/20)
Spelling and Grammar - (Out of 20)
I do call out spelling errors, i make them myslef, alot. But nothing is out of place, here. Even your punctuation is right on cue.
(20/20)
Total Score - (91 of 100)
Final Remarks:
Honestly, I'm not an anime fan, but this forum IS anime RPG at it's finest. I'm sorry i couldn't help with sugestions, and critique the forum like you ask. I just don't think anything's wrong.
What was most liked about the website/forums:
The skin, banners, layout, forum stats, etc, etc, etc ....
What was disliked most about the website/forums:
That i have never watched, or don't know anything about these anime shows/characters. Looks like a great fan forum, and hate i am missing out.
How could I get you (The Reviewer) to join my website?
Well ... i'd have to sit through hours and hours of Anime just to keep up with the forum, and it's member's discussions. If you did offer more off-topic Boards ( a little more organized) ... where i could get involved and get to know members. I just don't think it'll be possible in one off-topic board, where everything off-topic will go.
(91 /100)
I wish i could've been more helpful ... but i can't fix what isn't broken.
hcf
