24 Forum - Review

DSi

Resident
Joined
Sep 18, 2007
Messages
664
Reaction score
0
FP$
678
Hi

Could I please get a review for my forum ( http://24forum.net )?

If you need a test account, you can log on with username "test" and password "test" or else you can just create an account (email activation is not required).

Thanks!

-DSi
 
Hey,

Could I please get this review done? I don't want to rush anyone, but I'd at least like an estimate of when it will be done 😀

Thanks.
 
Sorry for the delay, DSi! Reviews have been backed up; but you're the next review according to dates topics were made.

I'm on this right now, should be within the next couple of hours. And, as i'm a member, i can offer a more detailed review .... just don't BAN me if you don't like the review 😛 it'll be a good one, though 🙂
 
Alright, just completed your review! And it was a pleasure finding a good fanbase forum, that complimented the actual theme that the forum is based on!

First Impressions - (Out of 20)

When i first clicked, as a 24 fan myself, i fell in love with the overall look, appearance, and set up of the forum in it's entirety. It is a true 24 fan's dream cometrue looking for the perfect place to discuss the show and meet fans alike.
(18/20)

Site Layout - (Out of 20)

It just shows when a true fan puts everything into something he really believes in, and wants it to work ... your forum is the pinacle of that result. Everything that should be included in a fan forum is there, and so much more, than, i myself, as a fan of the show, could've ever come up with. The forum skin/colors, banner, and overall layout, mimics the theme of the show in every aspect. Probably the best, based on the theme of the forum, and what it's based on, i've ever seen, and i've been around alot of forums.
(20/20)

Forum Statistics - (Out of 20)

Very impresive stats! You have a huge member base, a post count to compliment those members dedication, as well as daily active members to keep those members coming back and keeping every discussion up to date. I only had to deduct a few points, because some boards seem very not very active, with few topic/post counts.
(16/20)

Staff Moderation - (Out of 20)

I'm very impressed with your staff on th eforum, not just the number of moderators, but how involved they are in the forum. Upon registering, 3 moderators/admins welcomed me within an hour of registering, and posting my intro. And each post i've made, a staf member was there to reply, and really made me feel even more welcomed to the forum.
(18/20)

Spelling and Grammar - (Out of 20)

No errors upon spelling, and the Board titles and descriptions are pretty self explanatory ... the only thing i could complain is most board descriptions do sound repetitive as i read down the list (like post/chat about, etc ..); but that's all.

(16/20)

88 - (Out of 100)

Final Remarks:

There's hardly any knickpicking or approvements i could offer. The 24foxforum is a GEM! And looks like it's going to be aroun, even long after the show is cancelled (hopefully, never, lol)

What was most liked about the website/forums:

As a 24 fan, anyone who took one look at this forum wouldn't have to think for a second upon joining and getting involved. The overall theme.appearance of the forum "IS" 24. And, the 24 based forum games are addictive when you've got alot of members, who knw they're stuff, and can conribute there, as well. 🙂

What was disliked most about the website/forums:

That i didn't find it sooner, lol!!! Really, though, the only thing was that you have covered every angle/topic that can be made from 24, and to see some of those boards aren't too active.

How could I get you (The Reviewer) to join my website?

Joined before i even did the review. But, to get others involved, you just have to find those serious hardcore 24 fans, and once they find the forum, they'll come a knocking 😉

(88 /100)
 
Horrible! I'm banning you from my forum now! :evil:

Actually though, thanks for the very detailed review, it is very helpful! 😀
 
There wan't much to complain about, and i have a problem going into long rants when i review, and am critical. i just didn't want a super long post , when they're really wasn't much help i could offer. the forum is awesome, like i said. thanx for replying, and donating the cash, bud!
 
Back
Top Bottom