Number of Members: 6/10 - 8 members in 19 days is OK i suppose but the gap between me signing up and the person before was quite big. Number of Active Members: 5/10 - $ users have either not posted yet or posted once... Not very good. Number of Posts (spam or otherwise): 5.5/10 - quite low and a few spam posts as well. Appearance (first impressions): 8.5/10 Nice skin and logo and the logo goes well with the skin. I think you should get rid of the [Test] Rank as well. Layout: 9/10 not bad i think but maybe you should move the general discussions forums to the bottom. Moderation: 10/10 - your staff are all the most active members on the forum which is always good so they are all active. Activity: 6/10 - looking at the last log in times your staff seem to be the only active people on the forum, Overall mark (out of 100): 70/100 - abit of work and a bit more activity needed so you need to start promoting the forum and get you forum seen by more people.