Number of Members: 6/10 - 9 members in 10 days isn't really that good... You should really have more then that Number of Active Members: 6/10 - not many are active and half are not really active or have been active. Number of Posts (spam or otherwise): 7/10 192 posts in 10 days is good for a new board however some of them are form games and it is a promotion forum so you should really be having more posts then that. Appearance (first impressions): 7/10 the skin is good although it would look better if the logo was as long as the navigation bars as it will fit in more and would look much better. Layout: 7/10 - you could consider moving the affiliate box to the bottom of the forum as i think it would be better there. Moderation: 8/10 - all your staff are active apart from Chris who is a co admin and has yet to post. Activity: 4/10 Not very active at the moment Overall mark (out of 100): 63/100 - could do with a bit of work done to it and alot more activity.