Number of Members: 8/10 - quite good member total for the time you have been open.
Number of Active Members: 5/10 - 43 have never posted with a further 7 posting once or twice. That is not really that good as that is 4 of your 9 pages of your memberlist.
Number of Posts (spam or otherwise): 10/10 - What can i say? Fantastic post count especially as your forum is only just over 3 months old.
Appearance (first impressions): 7/10 - I don't like your logo much and it is a bit big and would look better if it was a bit smaller. I do like you images in the forum descriptions.
Layout: 9/10 - I haven't really got any recommendations on the lay out... It is not a bad layout.
Moderation: 7/10 - You have an admin who has never posted and hasn't visited since he joined in June which is bad. I think you have more then enough moderators but you should get rid of that inactive admin.
Activity: 10/10 - can't fault your forum for activity.
Overall mark (out of 100): 87/100 - I think you just need to change the logo or atleast resize it a bit and that is really all. Great activity well done.