[COMPLETED] Review Forumproject

[Online]

This is a project and experiment.
We are merely asking everyone from FF to join this endeavor.
This is to have as Close to ALL FF members join as possible!
To have a very Large number of FF admins in one forum, if you will!
Please join to see what this forum can become with the help of many!
This is a Joint Project that all members can contribute to!
Let's see if we can pull together and make this project happen!
We are not in competition with Any forum, but will help ALL forums if we can!
Help us mold this into a great project and see how great it can become!
All of us that are currently members of this project have forums of our own also - this is not going to be a threat to any forum!
Thank YOU in advance for your participation and help!
Please Join WITH us!
http://www.forumproject.freeforums.org

We are 3 days old

 

[CyberFreak]

Re: Review Forumproject

Number of Members: 8/10 - Not bad total for the time you have been open.

Number of Active Members: 9/10 - Most seem active although a few aren't.

Number of Posts (spam or otherwise): 9/10 - good post count for the time you have been open and for a new forum starting out... Well done -🙂-

Appearance (first impressions): 4/10 - Firstly your portal wouldn't load because my NOscript blocked it because of something from speakeasy.org. NoScript is one of the most used add-ons for firefox which is one of the most popular browsers so it could affect a few people and i was hard to get to your forum index meaning i had to get to your forum through the top of one of the pages on your forum like faq or search. I also don't like your logo much as it seems very plain, boring and i hate to say it but it looks like i could even make something better then that and i don't know the first thing about graphics. It is not eye catching. There is alot of fussyness around all the writing in it aswell.

Layout: 6/10 - I think you should merge Site Updates and Announcements as they are sort of the same thing also do you need a whole forum for your rule?

Moderation: 4/10 - I get the feeling you have to many staff. 2 founders and 3 Admins!!!! You don't need that many even if you have a forum with 4000 members. A forum with too many staff is not only a massive security risk but it isn't appealing to members if nearly every member is staff.

Activity: 8/10 - Good activity for a new forum.
Overall mark (out of 100): 53/100 - Not impressed really by the forum. Doesn't really look good in my opinion and way to many staff.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
Feel free to delete my account as i only set it up so i could see the memberlist.