Critique My Logo

[P8I.com]

This is the new logo I'm working on for my forum.



What do you think?

 

[Moneyman]

Looks good to me

 

[NoLifeNerds]

Looks pretty good, I'm a sucker for designs like that.

 

[P8I.com]

Thanks. Here's what it looks like actually on the site:

http://p8i.com/?styleid=2

I made the word "community" match the same size of "video games / tech" to keep it consistent.

 

[SP33D_D3MON]

That looks nice! I like the image lots. I was thinking how you could also put an '8' in there and not just the 'P' but it looks very professional. 🙂

 

[P8I.com]

That looks nice! I like the image lots. I was thinking how you could also put an '8' in there and not just the 'P' but it looks very professional. 🙂

I tried, but I couldn't think of a way to do that without making it look cheesy. I figured since I was going to spell out the name anyways, I could get away with leaving the 8/8i out.

 

[death180]

Love it.

 

[Tman123]

Wow man very impressive.

 

[Quacker Jack]

2 quick things, regarding your site's logo. First, On your forum put the text aligned on the left on the second line, as the center makes the spacing awkward. Or perhaps use what you did in original concept logo. Second, the icon is pixelated towards the top of the speech bubble / p area. It is minor, but it lowers the quality of the logo. Try and smooth that out and make it crisper.

Otherwise, solid, professional logo.

 

[P8I.com]

Otherwise, solid, professional logo.

Thanks, everyone.

I imported the logo from Illustrator into Photoshop (still as an Ai file). Perhaps that is what's causing it to look pixelated? I'm going to export the file in Illustrator instead and see if it makes a difference.

 

[Zaborg]

It's a big letter P ye? Kinda hard to understand. 😀

 

[Quacker Jack]

Otherwise, solid, professional logo.

Thanks, everyone.

I imported the logo from Illustrator into Photoshop (still as an Ai file). Perhaps that is what's causing it to look pixelated? I'm going to export the file in Illustrator instead and see if it makes a difference.

Possibly. That may do it.

And Zaborg is right. While the icon is visually pleasing, I'm failing to see the connection made. Frankly, you could probably rework the icon a bit as well.