It's on the edge, but that's probably the audience you're appealing to. Anyway, though, be expected that talk like on Gran Torino (with Clint Eastwood) is going to turn away many potential customers, but it may open it to others.
Looking at the design, the black and logo fit the theme and whether its powerful enough for the members and owners is a subjective thing. I mean, there are more eye-popping themes for XF 2, but those might be overkill and they won't be free.
Some will say it's not sports and wrestling oriented enough (not enough threads on the topic), but again I am more a libertine in this aspect. I don't think a forum has to be massively focused on wrestling/sports to be a wrestling/sports forum.
There is some porn. This thing is another turn-off to a lot of customers and advertising companies (Adsense etc.) However, though, there are ad companies which cater to porn.
Some will criticize the relaxed grammar etc. of the owner and members, but again, others will say it's simply the freestyle of the forum. I mean, what fun it when every word is policed?
