Forum Software Comparison

Nerdie

Paragon
Joined
Nov 18, 2011
Messages
1,922
Reaction score
1
FP$
6
Thought I'd write a break drown of forum software options available. I'll update this thread as I get a chance to test out various other forum software options.

vBulletin
An oldie but a goody, vBulletin is the choice of many forum owners. A possible reason to it's success is it's consistency, it has had the same feel and usability to it for quite some time and has become an interface many forum users have become use to. It has a pretty easy to use Admin Control Panel, which perhaps isn't intuitive, but I would say more familiar to many, due to vBulletins extensive use. As far as mods and themes go, there's a wide selection available to legitimate vBulletin owners at vbulletin.org, definitely something that should be high up on the consideration list when choosing your forum software.

Invision Power Board
Another choice that's been round for some time. This particular software hasn't remained so consistent, there have been several rather huge interface changes that have happened throughout it's lifetime. However, despite these changes, it has remained very intuitive and very easy to use. A cheaper alternative to vBulletin, it offers many similar features to vBulletin as well as a very similar, if not more extensive, suite of programs that can be integrated or ran independently. There is also a great deal of mods and themes for IPB, however, perhaps not as extensive as vBulletin. IPB is definitely worth a look and has developed into a great piece of software.

XenForo
It has to be said, I'm not as familiar with XenForo, so this isn't gonna be long. Basically, XenForo is becoming a popular choice by new forums. It has been developed by some previous owners/employees of vBulletin so might have a similar feel to it. It's cheaper than vBulletin, so again, might be worth a consideration. I'm not certain whether XenForo can match vBulletin or IPB on the mods or themes front, but it's shaping up to be a pretty good and becoming more an more popular.

phpBB
Right, well... If paying isn't an option, then phpBB is probably something you should look into. It has a great deal of mods and themes, on the account that it's free software, and is a popular choice to those starting a forum. I can't say I am personally a huge fan, but on the basis it's free, you can't really go wrong and should be easy to give it a test drive before hand. However, my main suggestion would be, if you're creating a forum for commercial use, or with an intent of making money from it at some point, I would suggest purchasing one of the above.

MyBB
I have use MyBB before, and it's alright. Similar sort of layout to the control panel as vBulletin, but not something that could compete. Mods and themes (from what I recall) are limited, but some are available, which can be found via the MyBB website. Again, this is free software and it should be easy to install and have a look yourself before the launch of your forum. If you're using the forum commercially or with an intent of monetizing it later, go for one of the first three options.

TinyBB

TinyBB is one of the most simple forum software around, It hasn't got all of the flashy and complex features of other larger, commercial software such as vBulletin. TinyBB is meant for people who want a simple forum software to power their community.

I'll try out some of the other forum software available when I have some time and add them here. Remember, this is just a quick guide to give you an idea of what to go for, but really, you should trial each for yourself before deciding, to see which best suits your needs.
 
Some I would recommend trying out are PunBB, FluxBB and Vanilla.
 
You should check out esoTalk too. I've played around with it a bit on localhost and I must admit, it's very appealing.
 
terryh said:
You should check out esoTalk too. I've played around with it a bit on localhost and I must admit, it's very appealing.

Thanks Terry, will definitely take a look into that.
 
Very good roundup, Nerdie. If I may suggest however, you missed a big one: Simple Machines Forums (SMF). They are a free host-it, like phpBB.
 
Quacker Jack said:
Very good roundup, Nerdie. If I may suggest however, you missed a big one: Simple Machines Forums (SMF). They are a free host-it, like phpBB.
I think we all know why SMF isn't on that list. 😛
 
Nerdie said:
A possible reason to it's success it it's consistency
Unfortunately that's no longer true. The launch of VB5 has been a disaster.
 
Everything after vB 3.8 is a disaster. IPB took the lead after that imo.
 
ooFox said:
Everything after vB 3.8 is a disaster. IPB took the lead after that imo.
I agree, the way they are treating their paying customers is most frustrating.
 
I think SMF and Vanilla would be great additions to this list. While there are some people on this forum who have issues with SMF and consider it the worst of the big opensource options, I think that it is a great software and with customization can function really well. 🙂

Great list though.
 
Sam said:
I think SMF and Vanilla would be great additions to this list. While there are some people on this forum who have issues with SMF and consider it the worst of the big opensource options, I think that it is a great software and with customization can function really well. 🙂

Great list though.

I have not tried out Vanilla yet. I am going to try it out soon though and will update the topic when I do. 😉
 
Quacker Jack said:
Very good roundup, Nerdie. If I may suggest however, you missed a big one: Simple Machines Forums (SMF). They are a free host-it, like phpBB.

I'm actually a big fan of SMF. It's worked for me for two years and I have no real complaints. Tons of free and customizable themes. Good plugins. Nice forum for support. So many SMF haters. But i can't see no flaws in it, even when they're pointed out. c:
 
Great review of the forum software, Nerdi! Do post more like these as you test out more forum software. I always wonder about all the new "indie" forum software out there that are not popular enough to be well known. There could be the next XenForo out there but no one is giving it a chance.
 
Back
Top Bottom