Inviting to review my forum

The first impressions I get from your site is very good; Yourself as an Administrator have a good level of professionalism and content spreading in and around the forum which has gotten posting off to a good start. The logo I feel complements the name and current (Albeit default) theme well and is of a high quality.

When it comes to forum sections, I particularly like your emphasis on discussion areas placing them at the top of the forum list with site guidelines, rules and other miscellaneous site forums situated at the bottom of the index; This draws users straight into discussion which is something not many forums do and is something I liked about your forum 🙂 When it comes to sections, you've kept it simple which I agree can be better as a user as you can quickly jump into talks without caring too much for category however I feel that when you have such an emphasis on such a few forums, you really need to ensure that things are done "properly" A use of icons on the forums as well as expanding a bit on forum descriptions would've enhanced the quality of these areas and made them stand out a bit more on the index. Also, while I like your attempt to tag posts with [brackets], they don't totally stand out and make it easier to search for certain things, in fact it's somewhat counterintuitive trying to differentiate title from tag so I feel making them colour do changing the background fill would be far more effective.

I feel that the area which let's your forum down the most at the moment is its lack of theme, using default themes is always undesirable, especially so when they're not edited or changed at all. I feel that even a basic free theme would be far more complementing to your forum and it's niche than the default you currently have.

I feel that while your content and professionalism is a strong point , more focus is necessary on both your styling and detailing in areas to really make your forum stand out from other general discussion forums.

I wish you good luck with your forum 🙂
 
The first impressions I get from your site is very good; Yourself as an Administrator have a good level of professionalism and content spreading in and around the forum which has gotten posting off to a good start. The logo I feel complements the name and current (Albeit default) theme well and is of a high quality.

When it comes to forum sections, I particularly like your emphasis on discussion areas placing them at the top of the forum list with site guidelines, rules and other miscellaneous site forums situated at the bottom of the index; This draws users straight into discussion which is something not many forums do and is something I liked about your forum 🙂 When it comes to sections, you've kept it simple which I agree can be better as a user as you can quickly jump into talks without caring too much for category however I feel that when you have such an emphasis on such a few forums, you really need to ensure that things are done "properly" A use of icons on the forums as well as expanding a bit on forum descriptions would've enhanced the quality of these areas and made them stand out a bit more on the index. Also, while I like your attempt to tag posts with [brackets], they don't totally stand out and make it easier to search for certain things, in fact it's somewhat counterintuitive trying to differentiate title from tag so I feel making them colour do changing the background fill would be far more effective.

I feel that the area which let's your forum down the most at the moment is its lack of theme, using default themes is always undesirable, especially so when they're not edited or changed at all. I feel that even a basic free theme would be far more complementing to your forum and it's niche than the default you currently have.

I feel that while your content and professionalism is a strong point , more focus is necessary on both your styling and detailing in areas to really make your forum stand out from other general discussion forums.

I wish you good luck with your forum 🙂
First of all - wow, what a well thought out and contentful answer!
I do agree about the above mentioned issues completely, but I have to be honest here - I do not understand these things that well (which is no excuse by any means), and would very much appreciate any advice on possible themes you could give.
Do you think a dark-ish theme would work best, or full-on dark (like leak) or a light theme?
I believe you have a deep understanding of this topic so I'm asking 🙂

I definitely agree about the category icons, and that is in fact something I will change quite soon,
to be honest the logo was somewhat random, but I'm glad it works as of now 😀

Thank you very much for your in-depth look and wonderful suggestions!
I honestly feel like sending $5 PP as a token of my gratitude 😀
 
I think it needs a bit more design but i like background. good luck
 
First of all - wow, what a well thought out and contentful answer!
I do agree about the above mentioned issues completely, but I have to be honest here - I do not understand these things that well (which is no excuse by any means), and would very much appreciate any advice on possible themes you could give.
Do you think a dark-ish theme would work best, or full-on dark (like leak) or a light theme?
I believe you have a deep understanding of this topic so I'm asking 🙂

I definitely agree about the category icons, and that is in fact something I will change quite soon,
to be honest the logo was somewhat random, but I'm glad it works as of now 😀

Thank you very much for your in-depth look and wonderful suggestions!
I honestly feel like sending $5 PP as a token of my gratitude 😀
Don't worry 🙂 I love helping to spread my thoughts, feedback and knowledge onto webmasters to help them improve 😀
 
Content is very well organized. More color in theme will help but other than that it looks very good and interesting.
 
I think a simplistic theme would improve the look and feel by a lot. Spend a little to get a professional logo. The content looks high grade, now just get the site looking high grade. Maybe add some more forums? The discussion is kinda limited. LAstly you need to get some friends on the site. Maybe find a mod to support activity. Best of luck!
 
Back
Top Bottom