Number Of Members: (marked out of 10) I think that 50 members is a good amount, but for the number of posts you have, I really do not think that. I see that you have barely any active members, which is not that good for a forum. But I think you have the right amount of members for a free forum. I give you a 8/10 on Number of Members.
Number Of Active Members: (marked out of 10) I saw that you really only have 9 active members out of 50. To me that is pretty bad. You really need to work on getting your forum more active and try to get some contests up, like who can post the most in a month or something like that. That will probably help your forum a bunch. I give you a 5/10 on Number of Active Members.
Number Of Posts (Spam or Otherwise): (marked out of 10) I like that you have almost 5,000 posts. Most of your posts are either spam or some good quality posts. But when I look at your other active members posts they are spam, like "yeah" ":O" or just some plain stuff. I give you a 7/10 on Number of posts.
Appearance (First Impressions):(marked out of 20) When I first came onto your forum I thought it looked pretty nice. The donate button looked pretty nice and I just really liked the look about it and the organization of the categories/forums. I give you a 16/20 on Appearance.
Layout: (marked out of 20) I really like the layout you picked. To me, the layout determines if you get members or not. And I think that layout will get you members. The layout you have is simple but cool in a different way, I like the forum icons and it goes well with the forum. For the Layout I give you a 19/20.
Moderation: (marked out of 10) I see that you only have 1 moderator and 2 admins. I think that is perfect for now, but once you reach 10,000 posts and 100 members, you should really think about getting another moderator that is active, and knows what he is doing. But I like that you have 2 admins, that way you don't have to do everything yourself. For Moderation I give you a 10/10.
Activity:(marked out of 10) Well, Like I mentioned earlier in this post, you only have 9 active members, Which in my opinion is pretty bad. But for almost 5000 posts, that is pretty good. You and your other admin are pretty active also. I like that you have a little bit more that 1500 posts. That will be a key thing in the future for your forum. For Activity, I give you a 6/10.
Spelling and Grammar(marked out of 10) Well, I see that you have good spelling and grammar, and that is a good part to getting people to like you and your forum. I say that because if you are bad at spelling and grammar, members won't respect you as much. But when I look at your other active members, they have horrible spelling and grammar, I think that is something you need to improve on. For Spelling and Grammar I give you a 7/10
Overall Mark: (Out Of 100) I think that your forum is pretty good, but there are a couple of things that I think you can change. One of them is getting your forum more active and getting some more active members. The other thing is that you should try to get your members to improve on there spelling and grammar. Well that is all I pretty much have to say. Overall, I give you a 78/100.