[Please look at this] Continue or not?

[Zaborg]

http://shareyourexp.com

I will edit this old topic so I wont have to make a new one.

I'm confused. I need your replies on this. Please!
-----------------------------------------------------------
Is this idea GOOD ENOUGH?
SYE - Share your experience.
General discussion forums, it's about sharing life experience, like movies, books, games.................etc.
-----------------------------------------------------------
I'm willing to give up and move on.
I feel like I'm just wasting time with this...I'm not sure this idea is good enough, that's why I need to ask others.

http://ShareYourExp.com <--- forums are not built up yet. And logo needs to be updated.
(I have .com and .info)

Thank you all!!! (I may send FP$ for best replies (any kind, negative/positive)).

 

[Josh]

Re: Need quick answers 🙂

Theme is boring, and you need to have more boards. It also needs an arcade. I also don't think the name sounds like it shouldn't be a general chat forum. 😕

 

[MissTake]

Re: Need quick answers 🙂

I've moved this to Peer to peer as I think it will get more notice 😉

I only had a quick look but to me it seem just like any other forum board, nothing really makes it stand out just yet, sorry 😳

 

[Zaborg]

Re: Need quick answers 🙂

Logo is out of shape.

And I'm talking about the overall theme, not about the content.

Old theme: http://shareyourexp.com/oldtheme.jpg

New theme: http://shareyourexp.com/newtheme.jpg

And peer to peer is DEAD.<br /><br />-- 22 Aug 2010, 21:06 --<br /><br />Well ok, I think it's time to give up. I'll leave FP as well then 🙂

 

[Josh]

Re: Need quick answers 🙂

Well ok, I think it's time to give up. I'll leave FP as well then 🙂

Why would you leave because someone moved your topic?

Hopefully you were being sarcastic.

 

[Zaborg]

Re: Need quick answers 🙂

No, because my idea sucks. (ShareYourExp)

And I can't find a theme which would be nice for everyone.

 

[Jonathan]

Re: Need quick answers 🙂

you need to have more boards. It also needs an arcade.

Bad advice. More boards? No. Why? It just makes the site look emptier and adds to scrolling. Arcade? Why use up server resources to distract users from posting on the forum?

 

[Zaborg]

Re: Continue or not.............?

Updated the first post. Please reply , thanks!<br /><br />-- 24 Aug 2010, 18:57 --<br /><br />I know that I'm being annoying and everything, but...It wont hurt if you reply...Anyone??

 

[Kahuna30]

The layout is really clean looking and nice!

 

[Zaborg]

I need honest opinions about my idea (whole SYE idea). Is it good enough?

 

[Deleted member 4320]

In all honesty I don't think the whole exp thing and all suits a general discussion forum and both styles that you have listed above (the images) I don't think they suit it. The current logo that's live is really nice but the current style, genre isn't right. Maybe start again but plan out more ideas for it.

 

[USHost247]

When I hear of "ShareYourExp" I think of some sharing experience with a certain thing..such as sharing experience with photoshop, etc. I'm not sure if I made my opinion clear or not. Also, you need a theme that looks more technical and gaming like. It just doesnt look correct for a gaming forum to have a business looking theme right?

 

[Zaborg]

Thank you.

You have any theme suggestions? (Any style, not only free styles)

 

[katy perry is hot]

Disregard the suggestion about adding more boards.

I would suggest you delete that PS3 board. What's the need for it on a site that's supposed to be for discussing anything? I don't get it.

Also, the theme is cool, but it's nothing special.