QneedA- Basic Review
- Thread starter Sam
- Start date
Thank you!
Your Review is In Progress!
Thank you for requesting feedback. I have tagged your thread, and will finish an official basic review within at most 72 hours. In the meantime, you will receive informal feedback from other reviewers and members at Forum Promotion. Once your official basic review is completed, you will be free to ask questions and receive feedback so long as your website remains open. You will also be able to request a re-review 14 days after this basic review is completed.
First thing I noticed that there are allot of questions with no answers to them, And they are all mixed together from Gaming to going to the moon. I would have different category's for each of the following questions in the right selection, so when I want to look for information about Cats i look under animals
Basic Review of QneedA
https://qneeda.com/
Review by Teg
https://qneeda.com/
Review by Teg
Honestly, I first glanced at the site; it looked like Reddit--a site that I hate the design of. The "hot" questions with their answers located on the main page are cool and all, but very drab. I do have to say that the flat-colored theme is appealing, however. There is no "logo," at least, not in the traditional sense--it's just text which is also boring.
Everything on the site is easy to navigate. I especially like that you have the option to read unanswered questions with the click of a menu button. The categories on the side fit nicely and also help with site structure. A big issue that I have with is there is no way to tell the total amount of questions and responses quickly like a regular forum. That said, this is far from traditional, but it would still be nice to have some type of member and post counts somewhere for us to see.
I enjoy the flat colored theme and the way it's designed. Starting from the bottom down, the logo needs some work. The text is way too small, it's very plane, and it doesn't catch the viewers attention at all. The menu items are neat. I like the larger buttons with icons, not many forums use that. I also like how "hot" and "Ask a question" are colored differently. Selected menu items light up in a lighter blue color which is good too as it allows users to see which list they're on.
Honestly, I do not like the list-styled set up going on here. Simply, you just have questions and their answers in a list on the main page. That's boring as I said before. I would suggest maybe a different layout. You don't have to get rid of the theme, but how you layout the site might make a difference. Leaving the header (logo & menu area) where it is, you could arrange the main page and include three or four columns and then add a section or two to each. The sections could be the categories each containing the five most recent questions. And, find a way to decorate it up a little bit. Make it so that the first question in each category has some kind of image--that represents that category--behind it. Just a few ideas to help make it a little less dull.
The site isn't very original. It's like Reddit as I said before. Simply, you have members ask a question and wait for answers. Reddit does the same thing with a lot more perks. I'm sure there are a bunch of other sites out there too. I can say, I've not seen a forum--other than Reddit--have this sort of layout. The flatness of the theme is unique, and the menu and navigation area is too, but the rest of it with the up down ratings, posting questions and answers, etc., is not original at all.
Overall Mark: (30 out of 60)
Overall, I think the site is an imitation of another. If you change up your layout a bit and even allow some different content, I'd be more inclined to enjoy it a bit more. For what it is, nice and appealing--for the most part--to the eye. Please remember this is just my personal opinion, based on years of experience. I'm not trying to hurt your feelings by being harsh.
Overall, I think the site is an imitation of another. If you change up your layout a bit and even allow some different content, I'd be more inclined to enjoy it a bit more. For what it is, nice and appealing--for the most part--to the eye. Please remember this is just my personal opinion, based on years of experience. I'm not trying to hurt your feelings by being harsh.
Cash has been Deducted!
Thank you for using the Forum Promotion review service. We have deducted 200 FP$ from your account in exchange for conducting an Advanced Review. You can request another review in 30 days.
I love flat themes and your one is great. The colour scheme is nice too. I noticed that on the top right there is a box with my username in it. I'm guessing it's for my avatar. I would suggest adding a default avatar as when there is nothing there it just looks odd and weird. It also seems most of your questions are getting answered so there is good activity on the site. Good luck with it 🙂
Affiliates
