Quick: Asperger's Network

R44

Paragon
Joined
Jan 31, 2013
Messages
1,614
Reaction score
0
FP$
2,188
Name of Site: Asperger's Network
Site Genre: General/Misc (by ratings here, at least)
Site URL: http://www.asperger.net.au/
Type of Review (Full/Quick/Questionnaire): Quick
Opening Date: 7/2013
Additional Notes:
Please try to focus on the whole site - as it is more than just discussion forums. And there is more planned.

At present, many changes have taken place for Beta 2 - so if you bring up something that has already been changed/resolved, I will reply saying it's been resolved.

Also, I'd like to be able to reply to this review before it is archived if that's possible.

Thanks
 


Review Accepted!



Thank you for requesting a Forum Promotion review. You will have your review completed in 24 Hours. If you have any questions regarding your review, feel free to ask me. While you are waiting on your review, why don't you take a look around the forum? After your review is finished, please rate your reviewer on how they did here.



Thank you for using the Forum Promotion Review Service,
Review Team
 


Asperger's Network
Quick Review by Lucky!


Analysis:

mostliked.webp Strengths:
  1. Content
    If I may be honest here, this is truly the best part of Asperger's Network. Upon loading Asperger's Network, I was brought to a list of articles that I began reading right off the bat. Something that I really enjoyed was the content within the news articles. What I liked most was that they were right on the homepage, which made it really easy to get to and gave me something to look at right away. Most of them were really in-depth and made me keep reading them, which helps with user engagement. The same thing with the forum section, there is a decent level of content that shows that your users are posting nice content, which others are replying to. With this type of website, I think that articles account for a majority of what your users would do on the site, and seeing a respectable volume is a very nice thing to see. So, very well done there. I really enjoyed reading them and I will be sure to read a little more as they are posted.
disliked.webp Weaknesses:
  1. The Unfinished Feel
    Something that I was quick to find was the very strong feeling of things being started, but never really finished. Now, I do understand that you're in beta, only because you told me in the OP. I don't mind that you're in beta, I really don't. However, what will reflect negatively is not letting guests know. If I was just any guest looking around your site, I would probably leave mainly because the site just looks, well undone. Let me get further in detail:
    1. News Articles:I like the idea of articles on the homepage, but they way they are displayed is not so well done. The biggest thing that you have something to do is to categorize your database of articles, something that would be easy for your guests and users to look through. Once I first started looking around, I notice that under the articles, it states "Posted in _____", so I went to click the link and it did nothing. Why have that under the title when it doesn't do anything other than link right back to the homepage. I was expecting to be redirected to the "Other" category or the "Asperger's Syndrome" category, but I was sadly mistaken.
    2. Double Navigation: Another thing that I was quick to find was how the navigation bar at the top had the same links that the footer has, why? I believe that having both the navigation bar and the footer having links is a great idea and helps with the user interface, but do you really need the same links in both places? You could have more of a custom area in the footer for something like a mission statement, or similar. Also, do you really need the "Stats for Nerds" section in the footer? For the average user, they don't really care what the levels are on your servers.
    3. Forums: While I was lurking around, I was reading some forum posts. I was quick to find a small bug, and that was the date. One most of the threads, the system said they were posted in 1970 at 12AM, which I highly doubt. Something else I noticed, the forums are dead. I looked throughout the forums and most of them had 0-2 replies to them, that's not a good way to present your community to a perspective user. I know you told me not to concentrate solely on the forum, but it's part of the community and it needs some TLC too, and right now, it's left alone with some dusty threads.
    4. Radio Page: While this isn't too big of a deal, it's something to point out. Once I was first loaded on the "Radio Asperger" page, the links in the navigation bar didn't load and didn't for some time. It seemed the page re-loaded itself and then it works. Something simple I assume.
  2. The Theme
    Another thing that I found was just how unattractive your theme is. Personally, it didn't flow well together and is just, well very white walled. The first thing I went to do was to look for a logo to press to be redirected to the homepage, that didn't go over too well. On the homepage, you have a very simple sidebar area which is okay, however, it's not nice to look at. You have a "Coming Soon" for the "Radio Asperger" section, which is fine because I guess you're in beta. The "No Account" section needs some work as well. Instead of just asking me to register, tell me what you do here. I know you touch on it in the header area, but not enough detail to make me register. Overall, Asperger's Network is clocked with a very bland theme that doesn't support the content, which is a shame.



Final Remarks:
Overall, I was not too impressed with Asperger's Network. The website has a very unfinished feel to it which isn't a very nice presentation for guests and users. I feel that you seem to have a lot of work ahead of you to bring this community to where it needs to be in perspective to where YOU want it. I will leave this thread open for a day or so to allow for comments. Thanks!

23kc11t.webp
 
Cash Deducted!


Thank you for using the Forum Promotion Review Service. Your FP Cash has been deducted, and payment for this service has been received. If you would like to give feedback on our services after reading your review, you may do so by clicking here!
You can make a new review request again on 10/26/2014


23kc11t.webp
 
Alright:

I like the idea of articles on the homepage, but they way they are displayed is not so well done. The biggest thing that you have something to do is to categorize your database of articles, something that would be easy for your guests and users to look through. Once I first started looking around, I notice that under the articles, it states "Posted in _____", so I went to click the link and it did nothing. Why have that under the title when it doesn't do anything other than link right back to the homepage. I was expecting to be redirected to the "Other" category or the "Asperger's Syndrome" category, but I was sadly mistaken.

Yeah, they shouldn't yet be links - An oversight on my part, apologies. In Beta 2 this has been resolved as things can be categorised to a new page.

Another thing that I was quick to find was how the navigation bar at the top had the same links that the footer has, why?

If you don't have javascript enabled, or are browsing from a tablet, or something fails - The redundancy is there.

I believe that having both the navigation bar and the footer having links is a great idea and helps with the user interface, but do you really need the same links in both places?

As per the above, yes - I'm catering for a lot of users that may or may not use javascript.

You could have more of a custom area in the footer for something like a mission statement, or similar.

We don't have a "mission statement" - More work to do ho hum... 😛

Also, do you really need the "Stats for Nerds" section in the footer? For the average user, they don't really care what the levels are on your servers.

Oops, thought that was staff only. Will resolve.

While I was lurking around, I was reading some forum posts. I was quick to find a small bug, and that was the date. One most of the threads, the system said they were posted in 1970 at 12AM, which I highly doubt.

Resolved in Beta 2.

Something else I noticed, the forums are dead.

Yes, well you try running a site like this and see how you go - It's not an easy task, and progress is slow - But the forums are in no way dead. There's new replies every day, maybe not hundreds of them, but there are a few.

I looked throughout the forums and most of them had 0-2 replies to them, that's not a good way to present your community to a perspective user.

And that's also a bug caused by a dodgy query which I've resolved in Beta 2 as well.

I know you told me not to concentrate solely on the forum, but it's part of the community and it needs some TLC too, and right now, it's left alone with some dusty threads.

I agree - But as one person who has one hell of a development job and a community to run it is far from easy.

While this isn't too big of a deal, it's something to point out. Once I was first loaded on the "Radio Asperger" page, the links in the navigation bar didn't load and didn't for some time. It seemed the page re-loaded itself and then it works. Something simple I assume.

Yeah, something to work on with the completion of the Auto-DJ.

Another thing that I found was just how unattractive your theme is. Personally, it didn't flow well together and is just, well very white walled. The first thing I went to do was to look for a logo to press to be redirected to the homepage, that didn't go over too well. On the homepage, you have a very simple sidebar area which is okay, however, it's not nice to look at. You have a "Coming Soon" for the "Radio Asperger" section, which is fine because I guess you're in beta. The "No Account" section needs some work as well. Instead of just asking me to register, tell me what you do here. I know you touch on it in the header area, but not enough detail to make me register. Overall, Asperger's Network is clocked with a very bland theme that doesn't support the content, which is a shame.

The theme has had some facelifts for beta 2, and I intend to put much more work into it, but at this stage it looks as though it'll be staying as I don't have the time or resources to design a whole new theme - and the site is all custom write, so it's not as easy as "upload, install".
 
R44,

Thank you for your thoughts on the review. I hope to see you around here again! Good luck on Asperger's Network!
 
Back
Top Bottom