Number Of Members: 9.5/10 For the size of your forum, you have a great amount of members.
Number Of Active Members: 9.5/10 Over 10% of your members have visited in the last 24 hours which is great. Maybe hold a contest or two for a download for a game online, or Xbox Live. There are endless things that you can do with a gaming forum.
Number Of Posts (Spam or Otherwise): 9/10 You have a good amount of posts and for the most part they are spread out, and not all in one forum. This looks good for potential members, since they will know that not just one specific gaming topic is being talked about on your forum.
Appearance (First Impressions): 7.5/10 I don't really like your theme. It seems plain, but it does match your banner. I also noticed that you use Traffic Zap. Most of the time things like that don't really work. I have used it before and I got no more members, just mad members tired of closing pop up windows. I would suggest that you change your theme or change the text color of the text that is red. Some people may like it, but I don't -~- .
Layout: 9/10 Even though you have a lot of forums, each one gets a good amount of posts, so I would say leave the layout how it is.
Moderation: 9/10 You have no spam and a good amount of moderators, but I think that your policy when it comes to spam is a little easy. Toughen up a little bit 🙂
Activity: 9.5/10 Over 10% of your members visited in the last 24 hours, which is great and almost all of your forums have been posted in, in the last week. Great job!