Number Of Members: 10/10 Over 1000 members in less than 3 months is amazing.
Number Of Active Members: 10/10 209 members visited in the last 48 hours, which is a lot especially for a new forum.
Number Of Posts (Spam or Otherwise): 10/10 Almost 80,000 Posts is amazing, especially for a new forum. Keep up the great work.
Appearance (First Impressions): 9.5/10 The appearance of the forum is great. I saw that you have text ads on by Google, but they don't seem relevant. Instead of having something like "Cheap DVDs" or "Pre-order Cloverfield here!" I saw "Used Furniture" and "Hair Donations."You my want to change these in the AdSense Control Panel to something relevent so that you make more money on your site.
Layout: 10/10 Layout is great you have a good amount of posts in each forum.
Moderation: 10/10 I didn't see any spam, but since your site is big I would be on the look-out for it.
Activity: 10/10 This isn't even funny.
Overall Mark (Out Of 100): 99/100 Your forum is great. The thing now is to make your forum even bigger. I searched on Google "Movie forum" and CMF was #12, but ironically I searched "Cloverfield forum" and CMF was #19, and under a free forum that has 3 posts! You may want to re-submit your forum to Google, to try to fix that -😉- . Also according to a domain appraisal site your site is worth $1,700!!!
Thanks for the review. The ads aren't down to me. This guy targets big sites and we kinda did an exchange. We have free hosting forever or his server (which is brilliant by the way), got upgraded to vB 3.6.9, and he also installed a new SEO mod (worth $150) free of charge which in time will rank us really high in google as each url becomes VERY spider friendly. In return he has those ads on our forum. He offered to buy the cmf for $650...we would still run it, but he would be free to stick ads and every thing on but obvilusly we said no.
I'm not sure what google you are using, but when i use google.COM and enter 'Cloverfield forum' we are 6th, and when we enter 'movie forum' we are 4th. Now concidering we aren't even 3 months old, I think its quite an achievement to be so far up. Bare in mind that other Cloverfield site you referred to has been up since Novemember I think it was.