@LordCraft This is one tick I do have with the software I'm using and I'll probably find a way to force disable it. But I must ask, did you mean threaded mode, not linear mode? That button can be confusing. The button shows what view you would be going to if you clicked it, not the view you are in now. Assuming from where you were looking at comments on a picture, you were in threaded mode, where replies to comments have an indentation like this:
Main comment, most recent
---A reply
------A reply to that reply
---A separate reply
A different comment that is older than the first comment
Am I correct? If so, I agree with you. I personally never liked that layout either and I'll probably put it on my todo to hard code the system to always use linear mode:
A comment
A reply
Another reply
These replies are always from oldest to newest, and you must use quotes to indicate a reply because they're never indented.
Forum promotion uses linear mode for their forums as an example. Not to mention threaded mode on my website has a couple bugs that the linear mode does not have.
I turned off the ability to switch between threaded and linear and am forcing everything into linear mode now as an experiment. If you get a chance to check it out again, please let me know if this looks better than before. Currently comments still show from newest to oldest, but are no longer threaded / nested. Let me know if you also think they should be oldest to newest, and any other suggestions you may have. It's appreciated ^^.
---
Next, the navigation dilemma. This has also been on my todo list for a while, but I have not receive consistent enough feedback yet to make a decision on how to restructure navigation. Ultimately, based on my research of the detrimental effects of the simple drop-downs, I want to destroy one of the two top level menus and have one menu that has just one item for each section of the website (Home, forums, content, journal, radio, and activism). What happens next is where I'm currently at a conflict with, and that is how to further structure. Given the amount of content this website has, having one menu with 7 items is not enough. However, having two top menus confuses people too. So I was thinking each section would have its own "left-panel" menu, like this:
My original plan was to section things out based on content subject. You'd click a subject, and you'd get galleries, blogs, forums, downloads, etc. based on that content. This, from my SEO research, is better than sectioning things out based on content type. The problem is this doesn't play nice with the navigation of each individual addon controlling that content, which could potentially confuse users even more.
So the second option was just to group things based on content type (eg. You'd have an item on the panel for galleries, blogs, downloads, and so on). This unfortunately is less productive according to research, but it may have to do just for now since it plays better with the navigation of the addons managing the content.
What are your thoughts?