Tips on Attracting Members

ros

Reputable
Joined
Nov 22, 2009
Messages
135
Reaction score
0
FP$
6
I wrote this as a guide for another site, as they had the same people making the same bad mistakes over and over. I see a lot of the same mistakes by new forum admins, and having been a longtime admin and a former support admin at a 15,000-member advertising site for several years, I see what works and what doesn't.

These can help you look more attractive to perspective members.

1) Make most of your forums visible. You certainly don't have to make all of your forums visible, but let visitors know what you are all about. The biggest misconception by new forum admins is that they will get more members by requiring people to register before seeing the forums or by hiding most of their forums. This will fail; I promise. Unless you want your forum to be private to only a few people, make it visible.

2) Aim for a sleek design. Your design doesn't have to be amazing, but avoid busy repeating backgrounds and overly bright colors. Don't make the banner a different size than your forum unless the background of it is transparent. There are lots and lots of skins out there for most types of sites.

3) Affiliate with other forums. Most affiliate buttons are 88 pixels wide by 31 pixels tall. A simple button with plain text that stands out from the background is better than something with a busy background. Ask for graphics help here if you don't know how to make one. Put your affiliates' buttons on your main forum index unless you both agree it's okay to put it on the portal index. Affiliate with similar forums as well as ones that are not similar but might attract a similar audience. I see some that refuse similar affiliates, but this just costs them members that would be glad to join both.

4) Put some information either at the top of the forum, in a welcome box, or in a sidebar telling visitors what your site is about. Don't make them guess.

5) If you are a graphics site - you better have a sharp design and nice graphics to offer straight out of the gate. If you are a skinning site, you should have a custom skin and skins to offer when you open. If you can't offer that, start another kind of site.

6) The most important thing about a forum is information. Put up information that is useful and relevant to your audience and those who you are trying to attract. This does require....work, and if you aren't willing to do that, then I'd suggest just joining a forum for the time being. Being an admin takes a lot of work, a lot of patience, and a willingness to provide a service to others. The most successful sites I know care very little about numbers; they provide a service, and they do it well.

7) Require people to treat each other with respect, and be that kind of person yourself. Many sites die overnight because of drama that could have been prevented if the admin had stopped it up front or was a regular enforcer of the rules. Don't let people trash other members, newbies, or other sites. Visitors come looking at your site, and many won't join a site with a lot of negativity or drama. This can also affect future sites and projects you might want to start. Write rules up front, then keep them and enforce them.
 
5) If you are a graphics or design site - you better have a fantastic custom skin on your site and nice graphics to offer straight out of the gate. If you can't offer that, start another kind of site.

Could you please elaborate on this? The top 5 graphics forums don't actually have a "fantastic custom" skin, if you realized. Its just a stereotypical assumption.
 
It does say "graphics or design". Many sites are both. But if you are a graphics site, and your skin isn't really sharp, and the graphics on it are not custom-made and very professional, then a lot of people probably aren't going to trust your level of ability to make graphics for them. It's not just a "stereotypical assumption". The 'top 5 forums' here are much smaller than the ones with which I am familiar.
 
then a lot of people probably aren't going to trust your level of ability to make graphics for them.
What?!?! Most graphic design forums provide graphics help, not complete graphics for people. There might be a section for it, but its not the main point of most graphics forums, that have succeeded. Again, another "stereotypical assumption". :/

If you go into google and search graphic design forum, those are the ones that are successful, and where users can rely on, regardless of posts.

Other than that part in your post, nice work. Really interesting. 🙂
 
I guarantee the reason most people seek out a graphics forum is because they need something made that they don't know how to make themselves. You have to impress those people to get them to join. Then, and only then, might they take some time to learn how to make graphics themselves.

I've seen hundreds of graphics forums. The ones that are the most successful are the ones that look the best and offer the most services for making graphics. Like it or not, people are fickle; they want immediate gratification.

Having 'googled', the number 1 forum that comes up has first in their description "Friendly discussion forum for free graphics design requests". Also, they are tiny compared with Red Carpet and Rebellion, which having just looked has 241,959 posts (and that's after they were hacked last year). And having been a member there, most of those posts are not in the General Discussion forums. Just because things come up first on Google doesn't mean they are the most successful. It usually means they are the ones that have just been botted the most.
 
http://www.graphicdesignforum.com/forum/index.php? - Simple design, bigger than RC&R.

And by the way, being first on Google is a big deal. That's the forum most people will go to if they're looking for a graphic design forum. There's a whole industry based on getting that #1 spot called search engine optimizaton...they didn't get it through bots.
 
That wasn't the site that came up first for me. It was http://gfxforum.net/ The site you listed looks like it's also aimed toward professionals, and not your average user. And as I said, RC&R was hacked last year, after being around 2-3 years before that. That's not their overall total of members and posts.

I edited that one section a little bit, but I stand by the idea that if you are a graphics site, then people will judge you by the quality of your site design, whether you like it or not. People will judge the quality of your site design no matter who you are, but if your aim is to help people with graphics, then they are going to search out the sites that look the best to get help.
 
these tips are very useful! i added them to my faves.Great job with this!
 
This is a great post. Fortunately I think I have pretty much followed these guidelines from day one, but you can never be reminded enough.
 
Everybody here has made excellent points but I would have to agree that graphics do effect a graphics-related site considerably. That doesn't mean you need to make the theme/skin yourself but it does mean it should be visually appealing. you can also argue that unless they go looking for a "theme by" comment on the bottom of the page, they won't even know any better.

But if the theme looks bad, not only would you question there technical skill but choice of style. lol

And whether you go custom or not, you should definitely have many examples of your work and members who provide graphics as well should be encouraged to do the same.

Also, not all graphics sites do themes, but some kind of area for readily available resources is always nice.
 
I've done a LOT of affiliate work, as our SEO stuff is already about as good as it'll get and we've advertised pretty much everywhere we can. Affiliate things I've found out are, well here are some of them.

Affiliate with both same and similar genres. For example my board is a warriors RPG. I affiliate with other warriors RPGs, other RPGs of any type, and warriors non rpg fansites as well as fansites that include a tendency towards enjoying roleplay.

Don't worry about your affs stealing your members. If members like your site, a flashy button leading to any other site isn't going to make them up and leave. If they do up and leave chances are they weren't happy at your board and were going to leave anyway. Most people who join through finding your button are guests on the site they found you on.

Ros is so right about drama. You got to be strict about it and nip it in the bud if you see it starting. Use a 0 tolerance no fighting policy and don't ever let a member tell you what to do, or tell any other member what to do!
 
Back
Top Bottom