Why Nofollow Links on Forums are GOOD

Ghost

Seasoned Veteran
Joined
Jun 25, 2009
Messages
3,585
Reaction score
348
FP$
3,264
Hello everyone,

My name is William and for the last 15 years I have been developing and marketing websites. In the last 3 years I have mostly worked with server side technologies and our user interfaces, but I do spend a large amount of time sharing our company (Wubur) website, writing content, and marketing as well. I hope to help some of you understand the concept of nofollow. In my experience, and with some common sense thrown in, I came to the conclusion years ago that using 'nofollow' links on forums is a great idea, and better for everyone involved.

If you do not understand what 'nofollow' is or how it works, it is an HTML attribute applied to URLs or links/websites shared on the internet. It looks like this:

<a href='https://website' rel='nofollow'>Nofollow link example</a>​

This tells the search engines that the link should not gain any page rank or special treatment just because it is linked to. It's possible that this link still can have an effect on rankings, but many parts of the algorithms in use on major search providers are still unknown to the masses. Nofollow was put into place because companies such as Google were experiencing difficulties with using linking as a metric for page rank due to the sheer amount of spam and auto-linking going on with blog comments and old / non-moderated forums. Nofollow solved the issue by allowing site owners to automatically apply nofollow to every link shared by users, or even on links they didn't want to be affected by the content the link is on.

Simply put, the way that SEO works is complicated and doesn't entirely rely on the number of links you have to your website. The content being linked to, and the content being linked from matters significantly. That's why you always want your links to be surrounded by content that relates to the link you are sharing. If you are posting a link to your website development company, then you should be discussing website development, or a related topic like marketing, SEO or project planning. It all comes down to key words and making sure your project or business is being linked to and from properly is very important.

The forum owner can't honestly vouch for every link being posted, and linking to hundreds or thousands of different websites (linked in signatures or posts themselves) can lead search engines to view the forum as being more broad than it actually is. For the forum users, a nofollow link can actually protect their website even if they don't see how their own personal content could ever have a negative effect on their own site. When you share a signature with all of your posts, you are technically attaching your website to the content you are replying to or creating. If you write a forum post about dogs and link to your website about technology, then a search engine or bot may look at this as your website being related to dogs.

You may find yourself constantly replying to discussions or starting conversations that aren't related to your website. This alone makes nofollow incredible. While you can control the content you share, you cannot control the others users in the community. If their replies are low quality or off topic it does not help your page rank. If the forum discussion is full of user signatures (NOT using nofollow), it appears as if the page is some sort of poor attempt at old-school link generating.

Without nofollow on forums, companies such as Google and Bing will not treat that forum as a good source of linked content. This can be less true for very specific niche forums, or for very well-written content that has high quality replies that also aren't diluted with other links. However, it's always a bit safer to have nofollow attributes attached to your links on forums. You can still get traffic on your website from natural human clicks (the main source of attraction here at FP), so it's worth sharing your link(s) even if you aren't gaining anything in the major search ranks.

You should definitely not disregard the potential of linking to your website in useful replies of your own across the internet's many blogs, forums, and social networks. If your site relates to the content, even if nofollow is being used you can definitely benefit from sharing the URL. I didn't want to jump into the fine details of SEO here, such as the differences between linking to your homepage versus a specific page or article, but I hope to have helped some readers here (either in the FP community or as a guest coming from a search engine). This article accurately explains why nofollow links are good for a forum or blog owner and the community members, but if you do have more questions I would be happy to answer here!
 
People are over-paranoid about SEO. Simply follow the lead of sites with high domain metrics - of course, with a little cynicism directed against DA/PA (metrics from Moz - which are sometimes misleading).
 
Unpopular solution: Ban signatures.

This is basically what most modern systems these days do anyway.

Discourse, NodeBB, etc. and even the real giants like Reddit, Facebook, etc.

Signatures are annoying distractions which don't really add to discussions and just drag you down. The only place where they're even remotely relevant is on a promotion forum.
 
Unpopular solution: Ban signatures.

This is basically what most modern systems these days do anyway.

Discourse, NodeBB, etc. and even the real giants like Reddit, Facebook, etc.

Signatures are annoying distractions which don't really add to discussions and just drag you down. The only place where they're even remotely relevant is on a promotion forum.

I would disagree. But I see you have signature - but this is a promotion forum! Anyway, what I mean is that plenty of niches are cool to have signatures - and others are fine with that - assuming it's not commercial.
 
I would disagree. But I see you have signature - but this is a promotion forum! Anyway, what I mean is that plenty of niches are cool to have signatures - and others are fine with that - assuming it's not commercial.
I wouldn't particularly care if Cameron disabled all the signatures here this very instant.
In fact, quite a few big board admin forums don't allow them.

Signatures really don't add much, and as you've seen in the case of the giants, no one even really cares that they're not there. People don't care that Zuckerberg is never going to add them to Facebook Groups and he knows it would just dilute the purpose of them.

I can give you a whole spiel about UX, but all in all, they distract from the main point of sites that is actually discussing things in topics. This is why everyone is moving away from them.

The fact that it hurts SEO is just icing on the cake.
 
I guess to each their own. Some hate them, some love them. Myself, I tend to ignore them. I mean, we see ads all the time for McDonalds, Coke, Pepsi, - but how much do we pay attention to them?
 
I guess to each their own. Some hate them, some love them. Myself, I tend to ignore them. I mean, we see ads all the time for McDonalds, Coke, Pepsi, - but how much do we pay attention to them?
I think it definitely depends on the website & the content in the signature.
Years ago I created a cool little PHP script that basically let us track affiliate clicks on links.

oursite.com?ref=30843208xnadk3&link=9083428alkax
That type of link would redirect to a website of our choosing (using an encrypted ID) and the ref= would tell us which affiliate linked to it. This project was only in use on HackForums. We had a group of 5 users who all put an image banner in their signature, and we all used our own referral LINK. We sold our signature space as a package for $20/week. We all posted a lot, so we got a buyer every week for over a month. We didn't make too much money, but it was fun and it was my first "official" platform that I created from scratch.

In that case, we were all posting in forum sections related to the signature banner's content. We got a few buyers for example that were advertising Pokemon Go boosting shops. We posted in the Pokemon & gaming section to get our buyers more traffic, and they did make tons of sales. In fact, we probably could have charged $40+ per week with the amount of traffic going to some of those signature banners.

So, I think it definitely depends on the community and the content.
For a site like FP, the effect a signature can have might be minimal. I personally don't click many signature links to join the site. I click signature links here to see what people are up to. For example, I found the Gosora forum software originally because of Azareal's signature. I don't know if I would've found it otherwise, and even with his Gosora thread I don't know if I would remember his associate to his software without his current signature.

So they definitely serve a purpose in a community, even if they can negatively effect SEO or at the very least not positively impact it. As for not having signatures on Facebook/reddit/modern websites, I think that is definitely the way to go. They're kind of a thing of the past and they often do not contribute to the actual discussions.
 
I guess to each their own. Some hate them, some love them. Myself, I tend to ignore them. I mean, we see ads all the time for McDonalds, Coke, Pepsi, - but how much do we pay attention to them?
I think it definitely depends on the website & the content in the signature.
Years ago I created a cool little PHP script that basically let us track affiliate clicks on links.

oursite.com?ref=30843208xnadk3&link=9083428alkax
That type of link would redirect to a website of our choosing (using an encrypted ID) and the ref= would tell us which affiliate linked to it. This project was only in use on HackForums. We had a group of 5 users who all put an image banner in their signature, and we all used our own referral LINK. We sold our signature space as a package for $20/week. We all posted a lot, so we got a buyer every week for over a month. We didn't make too much money, but it was fun and it was my first "official" platform that I created from scratch.

In that case, we were all posting in forum sections related to the signature banner's content. We got a few buyers for example that were advertising Pokemon Go boosting shops. We posted in the Pokemon & gaming section to get our buyers more traffic, and they did make tons of sales. In fact, we probably could have charged $40+ per week with the amount of traffic going to some of those signature banners.

So, I think it definitely depends on the community and the content.
For a site like FP, the effect a signature can have might be minimal. I personally don't click many signature links to join the site. I click signature links here to see what people are up to. For example, I found the Gosora forum software originally because of Azareal's signature. I don't know if I would've found it otherwise, and even with his Gosora thread I don't know if I would remember his associate to his software without his current signature.

So they definitely serve a purpose in a community, even if they can negatively effect SEO or at the very least not positively impact it. As for not having signatures on Facebook/reddit/modern websites, I think that is definitely the way to go. They're kind of a thing of the past and they often do not contribute to the actual discussions.

Well, of course, people DO pay attention to them (Coke, McDonalds ads etc.) - but it causes more brand recognition than direct sales. Well, I mean, it causes massive sales - after the fact.
 
Yes, that's usually best practice. Thanks for sharing valuable information
 
You are absolutely right - no-follow links are a great way of controlling the content you share. Yet I find them useful in one more way - they work great for balancing your blog or forum content. A healthy mix of do-follow and no-follow links is what you need to strike the principle of diversity.
 
Thank for sharing this useful post on benefits of no follow links. These links are good for brand promotion and add diversity in your mix of do follow and no follow links as explained by @maxxthompson above.
 
Back
Top Bottom