Would love some feedback!

[legalize]

Hey all! I'd be extremely grateful if some of you could provide any sort of feedback about my forum/website. Link is in the sig!

I've been working on it too long alone and have hit a mental roadblock a while ago, hoping to get some inspiration or criticism (loooove criticism!) or ideas!

Thanks 😉

 

[Hotspot]

Well, just from the first page. It looks great! Very professional, and a great logo!

 

[legalize]

Thank you! I'd love some negatives!

 

[nolvorite]

It looks neat, but sorry to say the skin of that board looks pretty clique-ish to IPB boards

 

[dojo]

Negatives: fluid layout - spreads forever on a wide screen. Better have it fixed, will look better. The logo is pretty nice, but too big. Maybe 70% would be better. Otherwise, even if I don't like iPB, the forum looks nice 😉

 

[legalize]

It looks neat, but sorry to say the skin of that board looks pretty clique-ish to IPB boards

The layout is the closest thing resembling the default IPB installation, not sure how it's "pretty clique-ish". Sure it's not completely revamped, but who buys software to turn it inside out?

Negatives: fluid layout - spreads forever on a wide screen. Better have it fixed, will look better. The logo is pretty nice, but too big. Maybe 70% would be better. Otherwise, even if I don't like iPB, the forum looks nice 😉

What do you mean spreads forever? I'm against fixed width.

Thanks, and keep 'em coming!

 

[dojo]

Well, if you use a 1600 pixels wide monitor, as I do, then your liquid layout is half a meter wide. And the lines of text are very long and hard to read. This makes some people (self included) avoid joining the forums, since it would put too much strain on the eyes to read 300 characters in one line.

 

[jglover4168]

looks good.. you have a good layout etc.. but nothing really jumps out at me if you know what I mean? try and make it more unique!

 

[Pvt_Tracy]

Your 20% off ad throws it off for me, it just jumps right out and takes away from the board. In my opinion, that should be on the bottom of that column.