Milk's Quick Review
Idea : 7/10
I like what your doing with your website, I see that it has some really nice design,etc. But the point is that, if your thinking long term, you doing all that work is not going to cut it and you will need some sort of script. What I suggest is that you find a script or get one made that will help you for the future of your website.
Design : 6/10
I have to admit your website's design is pretty decent but then again it is quite irrelevant to the main topic of the website. If I am correct, your website is about people voting a specific website to get voted per month sort of like Site of the Month on FP but the person doesn't really have to submit their site.
Layout : 7/10
I like how everything is sort out as of now, but in long term, as I said before I prefer you get a script that will help you and make it easier for you to handle.
Spelling/Grammar 8/10
I see that your "About page" has some great grammar and that is good, It's always good to have great grammar on your website, so high five for that.
Final Remarks : 29/40 73%
I think your website is still new and could be evolved into something really special, just keep working on it and it could be something really good.
P.S : Get a script in the future
😛